Skip to main content

THE FUTURES of LEARNING : What kind of pedagogies for the 21st century?

Author/source: 

Cynthia Luna Scott  

URL:

Date published: 

01/12/2015

Summary

21st century pedagogy should be based on three principles: personalisation, participation and productivity, where learners are no longer considered spectators, but active participants who collaborate in the creation of new ideas and knowledge. This peer interaction promotes the emergence of a model of “transfer”, where individuals need to apply new knowledge, skills and competencies in different situations (facilitating the acquisition of metacognitive abilities).

Pedagogy 2.0 sees a redefinition of the roles of both teachers and learners, co-collaborating in the production of course content. Personalised learning allows students to explore areas of personal interest, whilst a context of Problem-Solving based learning promotes building knowledge and skills in the process. This facilitates a shift from “transmission” to “transfer”, since collaboration and communication challenge learners to express and defend their own ideas and positions with the purpose of coming to a common negotiated conclusion. Seemingly, tasks based on relatable, realistic scenarios facilitate student engagement, creativity and innovation.


Limitations

When examining the author’s choice of sources to inform this working paper, it is evident that many of them are from research conducted in Europe, a few are directly from New Zealand and none of them really reflect the unique bicultural context of Aotearoa. Moreover, Scott cites findings from the OECD’s 2008 Teaching and Learning International Survey (TALIS). This could lead one to ponder where we actually are at in relation to delivering 21st century skills effectively when the research we are presented with is a decade old, particularly in such an evolving context. 

Another limitation comes, arguably, from the purpose of education. Scott starts from the premise that the purpose of education is to prepare the learners for the 21st century world. This definition could be considered a bit vague: does it refer to the 21st century labour market? According to the OECD, Education 2030 is about “helping every learner to develop as a whole person”. This aspirational profile for education is not that clear in Scott’s working paper. While the OECD document starts with this statement, Scott mentions this in the conclusion but only after saying that “learners are missing out on experiences that will prepare them for more satisfying lives and productive work”.

Criticism might also arise from the long list of requirements for educators, needing to not only shift pedagogical approaches but also become more digitally literate, design personalised learning plans, continuously create flexible life-like scenarios etc, in a context where an ageing population of educators is already stretched, underpaid and leaving the profession. 

Finally, the article is like an ideal “shopping list” of components/elements for a 21st Century Pedagogy, but lacks integration. What are the 21C challenges? What is the new profile of a learner? What is the purpose of education and schooling? Achieving this level of change across a school/the whole sector is still a long way off and would involve a shift in thinking from the school leadership, coordinated across primary, secondary and tertiary. The assessments/ qualifications/ standards don't necessarily match these priorities, particularly considering the schism between primary and secondary school.

Impact

Mobile technologies and Social Media have had a massive impact in the idiosyncrasy of the learners, facilitating collaboration and communication and giving them a voice; blurring the boundaries between formal and informal learning. These emerging new technologies offer a seamless integration between school and home life (learn anywhere-anytime). Learning outside the education system has the potential to offer students new opportunities (even student-driven) and educators can create learning environments that bring learners together, in order to collaborate beyond time and space.Technology can also offer an opportunity to enhance inclusion (for those facing physical or economic limitations). Despite all this, ICT on its own is not going to ensure quality education. Educators need to differentiate between the tool and the product, transforming themselves from content conveyors to content curators. In this way, teachers move away from delivering knowledge in favour of measuring and guiding the learning of students. The main aim of 21CE is to build the learners capacity to become lifelong learners and to do this teachers need to become “learning coaches”, actively constructing knowledge with learners in the classroom.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Open to Learning

Most people would say that educational leadership is about building relationships. However, Professor Viviane Robinson argues that "a lot of instructional leadership get stuck in the inability" to have conversations about the quality of teaching. Therefore, the real challenge is to integrate building relationships and 'doing the work’. Building these working relationships is not a question of building personal relationships and then “banking” on that relationship to have conversations about work. Staff trust their leadership on the basis of their observation of the leader's ability to do their work and treat people, on the leader's competence and their way of tackling people not being so. “The Open-to-learning™ Leadership approach [is based around teaching] how to build trust in teams and with individuals, while tackling the tough issues associated with the work of school and teacher performance and improvement” (UACEL, 2018). This approach is based on the

Heutagogy: A Holistic Framework for Creating Twenty-First-Century Self-determined Learners

By Lisa Marie Blaschke and Steward Hase Summary Heutagogy is a form of self-determined learning and is a holistic learner centred approach to learning and teaching. It is a theory that has been adopted mainly in e-learning environments and has developing capability, self-reflection and metacognition at its core. In the heutagogial model, self-determined students lead themselves through transformational experiences, becoming good communicators and problem-solvers of real-life scenarios. It was developed as an extension of andragogy and taps into the recent advances in neuroscience. A number of ideas, such as reflective practice; double loop learning; self-efficacy; self-determination and capability have supported the advent of heutagogy. Although some earlier experiments in this area (Steiner and Montessori) have been generally ignored, globalization and complexity are changing the way individuals and institutions interact and obtain information. In this complex environment, cura

Towards a definition of Digital Literacy

As technologies continue to develop, school and school systems become repositories of outdated terminology which, arguably, reflect how slow to respond to change and changing environments they are. The term literacy has evolved from a straightforward "capacity to read and write" to mean "competence or knowledge in a specific area", revealing in its evolution school's struggle to let go old principles. As a consequence of the shift in scholarly happening (as life moves away from paper-based into screen-based communication), terms such as literacy and fluency have seen a number of reinventions and redefinitions. It is beyond doubt that our lives are becoming increasingly permeated by technologies. Think, for example, of the Internet of Things, or Smart TVs or our portable mini-computers (which we still call mobile phones even when nobody actually uses them to talk!). This revolution in social practices has made necessary to define a term that can represent